PwC says AI benefits can strengthen the case for ERP upgrades

The consultancy says a simpler, less customized ERP core makes AI agents easier to deploy, though retailer Kingfisher is building its AI plans on top of its existing system instead.

· 2 min read

graphs of performance analytics on a laptop screen
Photo: Luke Chesser / Unsplash

PwC is advising IT departments that struggle to win funding for ERP upgrades to build the expected benefits of artificial intelligence into their proposals, according to The Register. The consultancy believes the AI argument can succeed where pitches based on modest process improvements have stalled.

PwC, which works closely with both Oracle and SAP, told the outlet that a so-called clean core makes AI agents easier to deploy. The term describes modern enterprise applications with fewer customizations built into the underlying system. Presenting that prospect, rather than small gains to current processes, could help IT leaders justify a migration.

Both vendors are encouraging customers to leave older ERP platforms. SAP wants users of ECC to move to S/4HANA, preferably in the cloud, while Oracle is steering E-Business Suite users to Fusion Cloud Applications. Such a move can mean sweeping changes to technology and business processes, not a simple software upgrade.

Many organizations still run these aging and often heavily customized systems, and the cost and effort of migration are hard to defend when the payoff looks like the same routine processes done slightly better. The Register cited a survey of SAP users from last year in which 95 percent said building a positive case for migration took substantial effort or was genuinely challenging.

Jennifer Colapietro, PwC's digital core modernization platform leader, said AI is increasingly part of the rationale, answering the question of why an organization should upgrade now. She noted that companies hold budgets for ERP and separate budgets for AI, and that transformation funding is now being divided between them. In her view, moving to a clean digital core helps companies realize AI value faster and start automating processes and implementing agents.

The vendors are pushing in the same direction. SAP recently introduced Joule 2.0 and Oracle has announced Fusion Claw, and both promise that customers can build AI agents to automate business processes and take over some work previously done by people. Colapietro argued that deploying agents on modern platforms is easier and more effective than adding AI around legacy systems, saying it is more challenging to apply AI to older systems.

Not every company is taking that path. Kingfisher, the European home improvement retailer that owns the B&Q brand in the UK, declined SAP's overtures to upgrade its ECC system despite approaching deadlines. Mainstream maintenance for supported ECC 6.0 versions ends in December 2027, and optional extended maintenance runs through 2030 at a premium of two percentage points on the existing maintenance base.

Kingfisher chose third-party support from Rimini Street instead. It is building an AI strategy around its current ERP system using technology from Databricks and Google. As The Register put it, AI may help persuade a board to approve an ERP migration, but it does not make replacing the system a requirement.

Related