Phylax DeFi security tool on Ethereum prompts censorship and builder concentration concerns
Phylax's integration with Titan Builder lets DeFi apps block harmful transactions before they settle, but researchers question freezing risks and the concentrated Ethereum block-building market.
· 2 min read
- Phylax's system, integrated with Titan Builder, lets Ethereum applications set rules that exclude potentially harmful transactions during block construction.
- Experts warn that apps could become effectively freezable if builders stop providing the required attestations, though Phylax recommends a fail-open default.
- Researchers also worry the design could deepen the concentration of Ethereum's block-building market.
Phylax, a security firm, has introduced a system that could let decentralized finance protocols stop malicious transactions before they are finalized on Ethereum. Cointelegraph reported that the tool has also prompted debate over censorship and over the concentrated market for block builders.
The integration with block builder Titan Builder was announced on Nov. 10. It allows Ethereum applications to define rules that screen out transactions likely to cause harmful outcomes while a block is being assembled. Phylax says Titan produces one in every two Ethereum blocks, and the builder checks transactions against those rules before including them.
The aim is to prevent exploits from settling at all, instead of depending on monitoring tools or emergency responses once an attack is underway. Phylax gives the example of a vulnerable vault that could wrongly release $1 million to a user whose shares are worth only $1,000. A circuit breaker could cap how much leaves the vault in a single transaction, stopping a drain. The company suggests similar safeguards could limit losses in large incidents such as the $6.3 billion Binance hack or the $380 million Bitget exploit.
Digital assets lawyer Gabriel Shapiro cautioned that applications using the system could become effectively freezable. Smart contracts can be set to reject transactions unless they arrive in blocks from builders that carried out the required checks. If those builders stopped providing attestations, the protected functions could keep rejecting transactions until the attestations resumed.
Phylax founder and chief executive Odysseas Lamtzidis said protocols can avoid this by letting transactions pass when the security checks are unavailable. He called a fail-open approach the sensible default the company recommends, but the setting is optional, so each protocol chooses how to balance safety against availability. Shapiro argued fail-open protections should be mandatory and that changes to the safeguards should be subject to time delays.
Researchers also raised concerns about builder concentration. Fan Zhang said the approach is only practical now because Ethereum's builder market has become so centralized. He noted its security benefits but warned that adding code at such a critical stage creates new failure modes, including implementation errors and the theft, loss or impersonation of builder signing keys. Researcher Sen Yang said reliance on a few builders for enforcement could give them a competitive edge and worsen concentration.
Yang added that Ethereum's proposed enshrined proposer-builder separation upgrade, slated for the upcoming Glamsterdam upgrade, may reduce dependence on third-party relays but does not directly address builder concentration. He said transactions excluded by dominant builders could still be included by other builders, which would more likely mean delays than permanent exclusion.
Phylax argues the system creates no new authority over transactions because applications set their own rules and opt in. Lamtzidis compared the checks to a require() statement in a smart contract. Stefanie Boss, a co-author of research on censorship resistance in Ethereum, said she leans toward viewing the risk as acceptable because the rules target outcomes rather than users, though she warned they could be misused to enforce sanctions or politically motivated exclusions.