Google workers urge reversal of AI requirement for school Search access

More than 500 Alphabet employees signed a petition against a policy that ties student access to Search to having some AI features enabled in schools.

· 1 min read

merry christmas, kids, girls, writing, pencil, drawing, notebook, study, friends, hands, childhood, joy, school, lesson, learn, draw, concentrate, friendship day
Photo: klimkin / Pixabay

Employees at Google are publicly opposing a company policy that would make student access to Search in schools depend on having certain AI features switched on. Engadget reported that members of the Alphabet Workers Union, CWA Local 9009, issued a statement criticizing the decision.

According to Engadget, Google laid out the policy earlier this month as part of its handling of AI features in its Classroom services. Under the approach, schools would effectively need to keep some AI tools enabled for their students to continue using Google's Search products.

Google's stated reasoning is that "Search and AI are deeply integrated." The company argued that a school-wide ban on AI would therefore leave Search unavailable to the students there. Engadget noted that this explanation sits awkwardly with the fact that Google operated for decades before it launched Gemini and its other public-facing AI tools.

The union statement said that any chance to bring positive change with AI in education depends on teachers being free to decide how to use it in their lessons. It also warned that cutting off Search for schools that decline AI will not win over users and may instead lead them to shut out Google products altogether.

More than 500 employees signed the accompanying petition. It asks Google leadership to reconsider and to let schools turn off AI features in Search without losing the ability to use Search itself.

The worry about schools walking away appears to have some basis. Engadget cited The New York Times as reporting that school districts in New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are each considering a different search engine, rather than give Google control over how students interact with AI.

The report does not say whether Google has responded to the petition or plans to change the policy. For now, the dispute shows how the question of who decides when AI is used in classrooms is drawing objections from within the company as well as from school systems.

Related