Author says data centers have become the focus of backlash against Big Tech

In a TechCrunch interview about his book Hyperscale, journalist Paris Marx links community opposition to data centers with wider frustration over generative AI and the tech industry.

· 2 min read

cable network
Photo: Taylor Vick / Unsplash

Journalist Paris Marx says data centers have become a political flashpoint because their effects are physical and local, according to an interview published by TechCrunch. Marx is the author of a new book, Hyperscale, which examines data centers and generative AI.

TechCrunch noted that opposition to data center projects appears to have been one of the factors behind the strong Democratic results in the recent midterm elections, and that the debate is likely to continue. Marx described the current buildout as "fundamentally unsustainable". He argued that residents anywhere on the political spectrum can feel the consequences in their power bills, water access and neighborhood noise.

Marx said his interest began with several local disputes. In Chile, communities around Santiago organized over water access as Google and Microsoft built facilities. In Ireland, he said, data centers now use more than 20% of the country's electricity, and the grid operator paused new connections for data centers around Dublin in 2022. In The Dalles, Oregon, he said Google faced questions about its water use while seeking more supply. A reporter at The Oregonian was met with a lawsuit rather than figures, and the company later disclosed that it used 29% of the city's water.

Marx also described his effort to enter a hyperscale facility. Many companies ignored or rejected his requests, and he eventually toured one in New Zealand. He had to send his passport ahead of time, and every door required a key card. The server room was not dramatic, he said, but a warm, utilitarian space with air conditioning and fans loud enough that long stays would call for earplugs.

He placed the opposition in a wider context, saying it is the most visible part of resistance to the physical presence of the tech industry. He pointed to objections to Flock cameras in the United States, Meta's smart glasses and Waymo's self-driving cars. In his view, people can challenge a physical installation more directly than they can an app they might simply delete.

On industry responses, Marx noted that Microsoft, Amazon and OpenAI have talked about dropping nondisclosure agreements in talks with local governments. He called greater access to information positive but said the shift is driven by opposition. He said companies are also offering to pay for more of the electricity infrastructure their sites need and promising different water-based cooling systems.

Marx argued that the industry has moved away from emphasizing renewables and nuclear power and now concentrates on water. In his account, companies cite national figures, such as water used by agriculture and golf courses, to suggest data centers are a minor concern. He countered that water use is a local issue, since individual communities can face real pressure regardless of national totals. The excerpt of the interview published by TechCrunch ends before he completes that point.

Related